Skip to content
iamcity
San Diego
city

Thu, 19 Nov, 2026, 11:15 am

Can AI Save Peer Review from AI?

Reported by today.ucsd.edu

Academic journals are flooded with papers. At publishing giant Elsevier, the number of submissions rose 56% in just three years – from 2.7 million in 2022 to 4.2 million in 2025 . That's a lot more papers. And peer reviewers, who generally volunteer their time, were already stretched thin.

While AI is almost certainly fueling the surge, it is also, as you might suspect, changing the peer review system itself. In October, Springer Nature and Google DeepMind announced plans for an AI assistant to help reviewers. Meanwhile, a working paper from researchers at Harvard says that AI-generated reviews can outperform even top human reviewers.

Zhe Zhang , an assistant professor of innovation, technology and operations at UC San Diego's Rady School of Management, thinks it's time for journals to take charge of how AI is used in peer review. In a recent Management Science paper , he and colleagues propose an AI-based approach that could ease the burden on reviewers without sacrificing scholarly judgment.

Zhang: It's too early to say if AI can save peer review. But we think it's worth trying.

AI is making it much easier to do research, analyze data and write papers. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. Yet some of those papers may look plausible without being very good.

Read the full report at today.ucsd.edu